
Two studies, two methodologies, two conclusions. All of it feeds into a final debate on the relationship between life expectancy and pensions. Unlike the study carried out by the General Inspectorate of Social Security, the one produced by the Chamber of Deputies' scientific unit, commissioned by MP Marc Baum, concludes that there are indeed differences in the life expectancy of pensioners in Luxembourg. Marc Baum of Déi Lénk (The Left) explained that these differences are very strongly tied to the level of income people have in retirement. The gaps, he added, are considerable, running to as much as five years, with those in the top decile, on very high pensions, living longer than those on very low pensions. That, he said, completely reframes the discussion, if the country is serious about pursuing a future pension reform that is meant to be more socially fair.
Health and Social Security Minister Martine Deprez took a different view. That conclusion, she said, is a bit simplistic. It might, at first sight, look as though the study shows life expectancy is higher for those on a higher pension. But if you asked someone in the street who they think tends to live longer, she said, the answer would be someone who is healthy, who eats well, who has not had an accident and who is not off sick every week. Whether all of that is directly tied to salary, she believes is in part questionable.
Baum stands by his reading and the differences are clear. The Left MP also had a point to make that goes beyond the physical strain of working life itself. It is not so much the hardship of the work itself, in his view, but what people have as a pension afterwards. Whether they continue to face permanent existential worry, which almost certainly shapes how much time they end up spending in retirement, or whether they can enjoy a rosier life on a very high pension, matters greatly.
Intern Catherine put together a fantastic quiz for Tom, John and Charlie and Rick in Devon had another head scratcher of a question.
Stay connected: Tune in to RTL Today Radio, now on 93.3 FM and DAB+, and be sure to catch our full bulletin on the hour, every hour, and headlines at half past the hour.