Off-plan propertiesGovernment announces reform of completion guarantee

François Aulner
adapted for RTL Today
The Chamber of Deputies debated the situation of off-plan property buyers on Wednesday, with Housing Minister Claude Meisch announcing that Minister of Justice Elisabeth Margue will present a reform of the completion guarantee around the new year.
All MPs demanded greater transparency in off-plan sales.

Minister of Justice Elisabeth Margue is expected to present a reform of the completion guarantee for off-plan property purchases (VEFA) around the new year. The announcement was made on Wednesday in the Chamber of Deputies by Housing Minister Claude Meisch, during a debate requested by the Left Party (Déi Lénk) regarding the protection of buyers in the event of a developer's bankruptcy.

In recent years, issues surrounding off-plan properties have multiplied in Luxembourg. Buyers frequently face delayed deliveries, inflated costs, or non-delivery entirely due to developer bankruptcies or financial difficulties. Consequently, many are forced to pay both rent and a mortgage simultaneously for extended periods. During the debate, MPs across the political spectrum agreed that the current system requires urgent reform.

Left Party MP Gary Diderich accused the government of favouring developers over affected buyers. He highlighted that developers benefit from the sale of off-plan properties, access to a special purpose vehicle (Prolog S.A.) provided by banks and the National Credit and Investment Company (SNCI), and exemptions on registration fees for properties completed up to 80%. In contrast, Diderich noted, buyers of stalled VEFA projects are left to bear the financial burden alone, covering surplus project costs, ongoing mortgages, continuing rent, potential legal and expert fees, and the risk of having to assume the role of developer themselves.

Legislative history and political friction

In 2024, the Chamber adopted a motion by then-MP Paulette Lenert of the Luxembourg Socialist Workers’ Party (LSAP) outlining ten proposals to improve buyer protection. However, frustration over the pace of reform was evident during the debate. LSAP MP Yves Cruchten expressed impatience, criticising MP Alex Donnersbach of the Christian Social People’s Party (CSV) for repeatedly deferring action. Donnersbach countered by pointing out that the previous DP-LSAP-Greens coalition had already announced its intention to revise the VEFA legislation in 2018.

Cruchten emphasised that the surge in stalled VEFA projects only began in 2022–2023, attributing the trend to rising interest rates and developers making poor financial decisions. While stating he did not wish to engage in a "blame game," Cruchten argued that the political sphere shares responsibility for leaving the market unregulated for too long. He added, however, that proposals for legislative action in the Chamber are frequently blocked by a lack of consensus.

Complexities of reform

Pirate Party MP Sven Clement introduced a draft bill, noting it remains open to amendments provided that swift action is taken. Housing Minister Meisch expressed alignment with the MPs' goals but cautioned that any completion guarantee relies heavily on the participation of insurance companies. He warned that poorly designed reforms could lead to construction freezes, particularly if disputes arise between developers, liquidators, and buyers.

Meisch raised critical logistical questions, such as whether the state would assume full responsibility and who would ultimately be tasked with completing the construction. He noted that some projects have been halted for extended periods, making it difficult to determine who should be held accountable for delivering a building that matches the original plans. Additionally, he questioned the feasibility of mandating a minimum ten-year insurance coverage in such scenarios.

Calls for transparency and next steps

All participating MPs demanded greater transparency in off-plan sales, particularly regarding the delivery deadlines provided to buyers by developers. However, the debate did not address the regulatory bottlenecks and administrative delays that often prevent developers from adhering to strict timelines.

Following the debate, three motions were referred to a joint parliamentary committee comprising the housing, justice, and finance committees. Opposition members urged for the committee to convene promptly to ensure the proposals are advanced and to prevent a repeat of previous legislative delays.

Back to Top
CIM LOGO